Research looks into abuse of grandparent kinship carers

Harriet Ernstsons-Evans • Aug 11, 2021
There are many different people stepping into the role of parent or guardian, and a proportion of these are grandparents who are looking after a grandchild within a kinship role (where a family member or friend is providing care). That’s the focus of a brilliant piece of research by Dr Amanda Holt and Dr Jenny Birchall, from the University of Roehampton, who interviewed kinship-carer grandparents who were sadly experiencing abuse or violence from their grandchildren.

• More than half of all kinship carers in the UK are grandparents
• The researchers spoke to 24 grandmothers and 3 grandfathers – aged between 40 and 73
• The children they were looking after were aged between 5 and 20
• They also spoke to professionals in family support services, social care, the police, education etc

The grandparents were experiencing a range of behaviour including physical, verbal and financial abuse – including being punched, kicked, bitten, headbutted, having items thrown at them, and treasured possessions destroyed.

Triggers for specific episodes could include going to new places, having contact with their parents, having access to technology restricted and the demands of the school day. But:

“The grandparents unanimously agreed that the violent and abusive behaviour they were facing ultimately stemmed from trauma and loss.”

This refers to the experiences the children had been through which had seen them end up in kinship care with their grandparents. Those interviewed felt sometimes the behaviour was the only way the children could communicate how they felt, and they targeted the person they felt the safest with – the grandparent who was offering unconditional love.

This abuse was understandably having a huge impact on the grandparents, affecting their:
• Relationship with the grandchild’s parent and other family members
• Marriage
• Finances
• Physical and mental health

There were varying experiences with professionals – contact with police was generally regarded as positive, contact with schools/colleges mixed, and there were challenges reported with getting support from children’s social care.

There are a number of recommendations made by Dr Holt and Dr Birchall, which we hope to see implemented by the services involved in supporting kinship carers. These include trauma-informed therapeutic work, tailored support for grandparents, thorough risk of harm assessments before kinship care is agreed, and continued support once the agreement is in place.

Speaking to PEGS, Dr Amanda Holt said: "This research highlights the specific challenges faced by grandparent kinship carers as they not only navigate the challenges of caring full-time for their grandchild - which includes challenges of managing contact with their grandchild's parent or parents - but also navigating the challenge of aggressive and/or abusive behaviour from their grandchild.

“Grandparent kinship carers are very much unsung heroes, and it is a travesty that this form of violence often goes unacknowledged, with insufficient support available for grandparent kinship carers in this position."

You can read the full research here.

By Amanda Warburton-Wynn 03 May, 2024
'Oh, we love having the grandchildren, especially because we can give them back!' How many times have you heard that? But have you heard 'We dread our grandchild coming to visit, we never feel safe until they've gone home'? Child to Parent Abuse is increasingly a topic of research but there is currently no formal definition and, if the consultation carried out by the Home Office in 2023 results in one, it's likely that grandparents won't get a mention in the main title. Of course, the age of grandparents can vary hugely but for those in the older age groups abuse from a child can be hard to understand and even harder to speak about. Whilst in many cases abusive behaviours are not linked to a health or mental health issue, some of the diagnoses involved in some cases of child to parent abuse weren't known until fairly recent times – ADHD was first recognised when mentioned in a National Institution of Clinical Excellence (NICE) report in 2000! Children who we now categorise as being victims of abuse and trauma were often just seen as 'naughty' back in the day and their behaviour needed to be dealt with by punishment. It's essential that we now recognise when children are asking for help – even if that is demonstrated by negative behaviours – but the impact of these behaviours on the whole family needs to be considered. Information Now say that In the past two generations, the number of children being cared for by their grandparents has increased substantially from 33% to 82% - almost two-thirds of all grandparents regularly look after their grandchildren. The UK Government add that 41% of mothers are working full time so it's clear that grandparents are spending more time with their grandchildren than ever before. There are myriad reasons for this including the changing demographics of an ageing population where many grandparents are now more physically active so spending time with grandparents can be more fulfilling than in the past (anyone else remember sitting in silence listening to the adults talk and drink team and hoping it would be time to go home soon?) But for all those positives, abuse of older people is a negative that's featuring more and more in research and in the news. Whilst several studies on both domestic abuse and elder abuse victimisation have reported that adult sons or grandsons, and a smaller proportion of adult daughters or granddaughters, are perpetrators in around half of all abuse against older adults (see Bows et al . 2022), there is little research into abuse by grandchildren who are aged under 18. One reason for this is likely to be the reluctance, by family members, professionals and society as a whole, to label children as 'perpetrators' or 'abusers Parents experiencing abuse from children have told PEGS that the abuse most commonly starts before the age of six and often continues post the child turning 18. It is probable that some children who display abusive behaviours towards parents will also abuse their grandparents but it's possible that some children abuse grandparents only. What is pretty much definite is that grandparents will feel the same emotions as parents if a child is abusing them – shame, guilt, worry about consequences of speaking out and concerned about causing problems within the family, especially if they appear to be the only targets of the abuse. It's also common to look for a reason for the abuse, something that has happened to the child perhaps or something that the grandparent has/hasn't done and to try to rationalise the abuse. As well as more research, there needs to be more recognition from organisations working with older people – statutory and voluntary – that Child to Parent Abuse can and does include children abusing grandparents and those grandparents need support. Abuse from a child is often no less dangerous than abuse from an adult so it shouldn't be laughed off or seen as grandparents not having enough 'control' over their grandchildren. More awareness of the issue, more open discussions and acknowledgement of the impact of this type of abuse will hopefully lead to appropriate support for grandparents who come forward to ask for help, and more of them doing so. Amanda Warburton-Wynn is an independent researcher and consultant specialising in support for domestic abuse and sexual violence survivors with disabilities and older people. You can find out more about Amanda and her work on her website www.awdaconsultancy.com
By Michelle John 12 Apr, 2024
Promotions and a new director for PEGS
By Michelle John 22 Mar, 2024
PEGS turns 4
Share by: